Bright Waters Catskill

November first, and the winds have been howling today! It’s not cold, in the seventy-degree range and sunny, but with winds that could knock you down if you aren’t prepared for them. I think of these as winter winds, for in my Catskill Mountain world there are but two seasons: dry fly season and winter.

I conceded to the end of dry fly season yesterday when an eight-inch brownie grabbed my dry fly as I stripped it in for another cast. The sun was brilliant with record temperatures flirting with eighty degrees, and that drove the water temperatures up close to fifty with the thinning flows. Nothing rose, though I did see a couple of long distance splashes indicative of something sizeable chasing minnows.

Even without those winds, this first Friday of November was earmarked for chores. The wear and tear on my old porch needed some paint and wood filler, and the warm conditions are perfect for that. In between I took the cans and bottles to recycling and removed the tackle bag from the SUV. The reel with the floating fly was put up too, replaced with the holy one spun with the clear intermediate line I use for occasional winter fishing. Holy isn’t ecclesiastical in nature by the way, it’s just how I think of that machined fly reel that seems to have more holes than aluminum, the better to shake off water and dry the line before it can freeze.

I am clear to get back to the mountains now and try to find a grouse or two in the dry forest. That can be tough, but I hope a few places along some small streams will prove productive.

In a couple of weeks it will be deer season, another forest pursuit that will help take my mind away from fishing while I give the rivers and the spawning trout the rest they so richly deserve. A number of deer hunters would be clearing out their freezers about this time of year too, but I have no illusions about my luck. Any venison that finds it’s way in there comes as a gift from friends. I do still enjoy walking in the mountains and looking for a buck though.

Once the spawn is over and we hopefully get some rain to bring river flows back to normal, I usually take a day here and there when some warmer southern winds push the thermometer upwards from the winter norm. Walk a riverbank and swing a fly through likely feeding areas, easy fishing, without expectations.

There is a winter project that I am looking forward to: the chance to turn a piece of Lo o bamboo into a 7’9″ five weight fly rod. I plan to start by flaming that internode section of a culm, something I will undoubtedly look to my friend Dennis Menscer to supervise. I like the warm brown color of flamed bamboo, and flaming will also accomplish the heat treating necessary. After that, the real work begins.

I am leaning toward one of my friend Tom Whittle’s tapers. He makes a sweet, powerful 7’9″ 3-piece five weight rod that I got a chance to cast at the Catskill Gathering in 2022. I like the idea of making a rod from a taper I have cast or fished with before. The Vietnamese bamboo will make my rod a little lighter, and it will be nodeless! Bamboo nodes add a lot of work to making a fly rod, as they must be pressed, sanded, filed and straightened, as well as staggered when the strips are laid out for the blank. If everything goes well, I will have a new rod to fish when spring awakens the trout and the mayflies: the first and only Angler’s Rest Special.

Have Quill Gordon, will travel.

The wait begins…

I used to look forward to this holiday. As a bowhunter, Halloween brought the best time of the season for crossing paths with a big whitetail buck! I can still recall the details of some of those encounters, though there has never been that dreamed of mount of a Pope & Young whitetail on my wall to spur those memories. A decent hunter, but never lucky.

It has been a decade I guess since I last entered the forest with a bow and arrows. My chosen stick and string come October is a fly rod, line and leader, my arrow the dry fly.

Halloween pretty firmly marks the end of the dry fly season. In that sense, it brings a sense of loss after seven months of casting flies to shy wild trout.

Depending upon whose word one trusts, our region achieved a record temperature yesterday and could well scale that height again today. The warm air and sunshine will warm the flowing waters once more, giving hope to lost souls like mine that a good trout might just rise to our fly.

Thoughts of the whitetail rut which once captivated me at this season will be far away as I wade shallow waters, searching for a trout concerned more with a fluttering meal than a spawning tributary. I found a trout like that a couple of seasons past, but that was a year with much better river flows. This October has given the Catskill watersheds less than an inch of rainfall. Our annual average for the month is better than four inches.

Here upon November’s doorstep, our ten-day forecast predicts a total of some three-tenths of an inch of rain over the period. Even if we got all of that at once it would be far too little. Spread out over several days it is nothing.

I may find a good trout on the feed, though my focus will be on enjoying this one last day of warmth and solitude before winter finds her way into these mountains. As much as I will cherish this day, I would gladly trade it for a day long rain.

The iridescence of autumn is waning as is the ephemeral magic of another Catskill dry fly season. It will be November before the week is out, and I will be forced finally to transition to the long months of winter.

I cling to these last moments, these final hopes and dreams each season. The days when I truly expect a good trout to rise to my fly are long past, yet I will continue the search I begin each March, for when that search has ended, I shall be separated from the rivers of my heart.

It is my custom to tear myself away from these bright waters once these last days of my true fly-fishing season have come and gone. Yes, after a time, I will likely return to the river. Winter forays are few though, and do not carry the promise of beauty and energy that draw me there from March through October. I like to rest the trout as they pursue their procreation and turn my attentions to the mountains.

December is often a month when I will seek a few moments of solace upon bright water. I carry an old rod, swing a fly for a couple of hours during the warmest portion of the day, gaze at the cold, wintry light upon the mountainsides and the water. You could call it fishing, though it is more about my soul seeking some brief reconnection to the rivers of my heart, sustenance to hold on through the remainder of the winter.

Once those early days of winter have passed, there are often long stretches of time away. Through the middle of a Catskill winter storms pass through and the deepest cold settles into these mountains. Some years there are little breaks, calm mornings where the sun actually lends some warmth to stimulate the rivers. As anglers, we too are stimulated, though falsely. Still, it is comforting to steal a bright winter’s morn and fell my feet upon gravel, my hand curl about the cork of an old cane rod.

The first early warning notes I have heard predict a wet winter for the Catskills. We need that to refill the reservoirs depleted for construction, but we need snow in the high country as well. Gradually melting mountain snowpack replenishes the springs from which our rivers are born. It is the key to Nature’s water cycle.

I cherish these morning hours as I prepare for the day’s fishing. Checking gages and forecasts, often tying a few flies my instincts tell me might be needed. In a moment I will choose the rod I will fish today, slip it from it’s tube and wipe down the ferrules, then decide which reel to set aside with my cup of fresh dry flies. I am thinking Dennis Menscer’s hollowbuilt five weight will feel just right with the Hoagy Carmichael Perfect…

I made the right decisions: a warm base layer beneath fleece lined khakis and a 300-weight fleece pullover, topped off with one of my favorite Thermoball jackets. The day featured the promised sunshine, and to some the winter wear might seem excessive, but wading waist deep in 45-degree water will take the heat right out of the body.

As it was, I remained relatively comfortable and made the right decision regarding fly pattern too, tying on a freshly tied Pale Isonychia 100-Year Dun and putting my faith there for the duration.

The rainbow surprised me somewhat, grabbing the fly as it had nearly drifted back to me. There was no doubt he was a quality fish, for the Paradigm had arched into a full bend straight away and stayed there, it’s tip bouncing with each frantic thrust. We were in faster water too, just where a Delaware rainbow likes to be, even it seems in forty something water.

I got him in the net on the second try, all seventeen inches of him, and I thanked him for his service. I never found another in all that lovely fast water, eventually turning downriver and working some favorite lies. The Red Gods obviously felt I was being greedy on this autumn day, for they conspired to take one away from me just to keep my enthusiasm in check.

It was near the place I had missed a big fish two days prior, and once more the confounded glare played a role. The sun you see is in a different quarter than it likes on a summer morning, and that complicates my usual downstream casting approach. My foot began to slip into a deeper spot during the drift you see, and I was already dunking the lower pockets of my vest. I glanced away from the fly, resettled my foot up and to the rear, glanced back just as the gentle plop revealed another of those coffee cup sized rings. There was never any hope of hooking him…

The Catskill Fly Tyers Guild held our last live meeting of the year yesterday, a very well attended gathering in the Wulff Gallery of the Catskill Fly Fishing Center and Museum. Our Catskill authors and legends were well represented by Ed and Judy Van Put, Dave Catizone, John Shaner and Tom Mason. A couple of members came from rather long distances to join us for a comfortable afternoon of tying Catskill flies. I’ll miss the comradery of this fine group of gentlemen until we gather again in spring, though we will continue our online Zoom meetings during the long winter.

One of the travelers showed me his ties for my CDX caddis pattern which I had demonstrated in one of last winter’s Zoom sessions, and I was pleased to see the fine job he did tying them. The Guild is all about sharing patterns and ideas and we all enjoy it when another angler finds some appreciation for our craft. May those flies catch your dreams my friend!

I am still holding out for another spark of dry fly magic before winter takes a firm and unrelenting grip upon the rivers of my heart. The popup weather report on my computer this morning claimed it was 31 degrees outside but felt like 26. We are often a degree or two colder here in Crooked Eddy, though that tends to be compensated for during summer days with a few degrees of extra warmth.

There is a certain serenity walking a deserted Catskill river corridor under an autumn sun. Carrying a favorite bamboo rod adorned with a crisply hackled dry fly completes the mood.

It is Friday the twenty-fifth of October and thirty-one degrees at Crooked Eddy. There’s a solid frost on the SUV which the sun will dissipate, once it burns off the morning haze. The river too has cooled overnight; thus, I will not hurry despite my need to feel the chill and contentment as the current caresses my legs.

The forecast is for calm winds and that sunshine, though the temperature will be somewhere near sixty degrees at it’s peak, and the Paradigm will accompany me on yet another try to extend the dry fly season. I have cleaned and lubricated the fly line on the old Perfect, tied better than half a dozen dry flies and am enjoying the last sip of my second cup of coffee. Life is good.

I found the pale, tannish variation of the Isonychia duns on the water last September. Serendipitously, one landed upon my hand allowing close observation. Of course I blended dubbing to tie this unusual body, ribbed it with claret thread to mimic the venation observed on that natural, and fished the new fly. It produced well during that season, and it was one of those same patterns which brought me so close to success two days past.

This morning, I tied a selection of duns and emergers, hoping that the frost and drop in water temperature might be mitigated by sunshine and lower water. Soon I must complete my preparations and begin my search for the opportunity to drift these upon the current.

One hundred seven days, and drawing swiftly toward the close of a season that began on April 10th, before an onslaught of high, cold water robbed me of nearly a fortnight. Low water followed closely as spring blended into summer, until the rivers were ravaged by the remains of Hurricane Debby. It seemed the rivers would never clear, and then drought returned. It continues still.

Each season has interruptions, but this year’s crop was more insidious. There were long periods characterized by fruitless days upon the water, days simply devoid of opportunities or challenges, as if Nature deemed it time to balance the scales. I have been fortunate throughout these half dozen seasons upon the rivers of my heart.

All days spent fishing are good days. Each true angler knows that, for there is indeed much more involved with this passion for angling than netted trout. None of us object to success, and none to challenge.

Thursday, October 24th here in Crooked Eddy, and that taste of Indian Summer has passed. Rather than temperatures spiraling toward eighty, this day will settle in close to the mark we have before dawn: fifty-two degrees.

I wandered the rivers throughout this week’s meteorological celebration, taking in the warm sunshine, in search of opportunities for the dry fly. Though a few presented themselves, all were fleeting, from Monday’s brief moving target, to Wednesday’s challenging doorway to bliss.

I cannot say I had no chance on that last day. As I sit and contemplate my fate, I play the moment back in my mind.

I was working upriver when the winds rose suddenly, turning the calm beauty of the afternoon into a whirlwind of leaves in the air and on the water. I had tied an Isonychia 100-Year Dun to my leader, an act of hope more than a play on some hidden knowledge, but when I saw a tall-winged mayfly drifting between the wind tossed leaves, I knew my choice had been sound.

Moving toward a familiar piece of cover, my eyes searched for pockets of calm along the shoreline. There were few of them, the surface repeatedly tossed by the gusts, and there were very few of those big flies. A handful of mayflies at this time of year, drifting through the closing hours of the dry fly season, spurred me to stalk and cast to each little oasis I managed to find.

My story is an old one, familiar to every angler. The glaring sun in my right eye, the unpredictable gusts accelerating from the steady blow adding challenges to an already unlikely endeavor, but this is the spark that makes the sporting life worthwhile. As one gust ended, I released the line and sent my fly toward a tiny corner along a windblown bank. As my shoulders turned, the hood shifted on my head, exposing my eye to that glare, just as a new minor gust hit my moving fly line. I believed my fly had landed on target, but my compromised vision could not fix it amid the drifting leaves. The take was quick and subtle, a coffee cup sized ring just on the edge of land and water, and my reaction was not the cool, well-planned pause and lift that breeds success.

I saw a few more isonychia duns as I fished on upriver, but no rises came to either natural or imitation there in the full strength of those late October winds. I fished back down that riverbank, though quickly as time was short. I kept asking for a few moments of calm, a second gift with which I might salvage the first one offered.

An Isonychia dun came wriggling past that same tiny corner and the water surged with the rise of the kind of trout I had fully expected to be holding there. I did my best to drift my fly repeatedly through that window, changed the pattern and tried again, but no fly I could offer would skitter and bounce twisting upon the surface the way that lone, irresistible mayfly had.

I struggled to fish out the afternoon, but it seemed as if every leaf in the forest had been directed into all of the primary lines of drift. There would be no second chance, however grateful I might be for the first.

Seventy-one degrees yesterday, as I turned the car north along NY Route 8; a last taste of Catskill Summer? We were headed to Earleville, NY and it’s historic Opera House to see our friend Nate Gross and his band release their new album of rockin’ blues “Ride With The Devil”. The sunshine lit up the remaining colors on the mountainsides and got me to thinking of the hidden promise of the next few days.

The forecasters tell us the temperatures will climb through mid-week before dropping more than twenty degrees on Thursday, wiping away the last euphoria of summer in one swift stroke. The angler in me retains just a bit of hope that this last burst of seventy-degree sunshine might convince a few mayflies to take wing, and those trout not yet occupied with spawning to rise to Nature’s last banquet of the season.

I walked the river on Wednesday afternoon, feeling the chill of the water penetrate every layer I had donned despite the sunshine. When the sun topped the ridgeline and allowed the shade to take rapid possession of the pool I shivered. I did at least see a rise, though nothing sustained, nothing in range of a cast. In my heart, I had already surrendered to the inevitability of winter.

The high release levels on the Delaware tailwaters have finally begun to decline, though not by enough to warm the waters downstream. Trout remain unlikely to rise with water temperatures in the forties and very small hatches of flies. Our freestone streams should be spared the intrusion of anglers now. It is spawning time, and they remain pitifully low. My hope now is that we will have plentiful rains before we have freezing temperatures, for anchor ice takes no prisoners.

The long-term discussion speaks of a La Nina winter, wetter than normal for the Northeastern states. I hope this comes to pass, and though shoveling snow is not high on my activity list, I hope our mountains enter spring with a good snowpack.

I know full well it may be six months before I tighten into a soft riseform and feel that magnificent throb of life in a full arc of split bamboo. I am thankful that my ears will have the music of Nate’s guitar to replace the special tones of a vintage Hardy reel and a large, wild Catskill trout streaking for the horizon. Nate’s blues will help me find my way to springtime. http://www.musicbynategross.com

It seems as though Saturday’s Fly Tyer’s Roundtable has served as an inauguration of our winter fly tying season, as the weather remains unfriendly for fishing the dry flies we Catskill fly tyers love to tie.

I looked up from tying a 100-Year Dun to see the face and camera of Mr. Richard Lodge who has graced us with a wonderful new book about the life of Rueben R. Cross, one of the most heralded Catskill fly tyers, and the man many praise as the father of the Catskill School. I was pleased to meet this author, shake his hand and tell him face to face how much I enjoyed his book. If you are a fly tyer, or wish to be, this is one you should read! “The Rise of the Neversinker, Fly Tier Rube Cross” is published by Plaidswede Publishing in Concord, New Hampshire and is available from the author via his website https://crossingtherubicon.net

Our brief meeting got me thinking about Cross once more, so I read the book again today. That got me to open the packet of dubbing I had blended last winter for Rueb’s signature fly, the Cross Special. Looking through the box that houses my dun hackle capes, I latched onto the perfect Charlie Collins gray toned medium dun and tied a few of those Specials in both traditional Catskill and my own 100-Year Dun styles. If I am fortunate to find a few more of the cream-colored mayflies that have danced upon the river these past two weeks, I shall be ready!

A little rain did grace the Catskills on Sunday and overnight, though not nearly enough without being followed by some steady reinforcements. I’ll waste no time in getting out to prospect tomorrow, cane rod in hand.

Wednesday’s forecast still calls for snow showers, making me think I should be out in the mountains in search of a grouse or two. Snow on the mountain is somehow better than snow on the river, and those forested slopes are a better place to welcome the first real sign of winter if it comes.

Mid-October and it is forty degrees here in Crooked Eddy. The sun was warm yesterday as we gathered in the Wulff Gallery for our autumn Fly Tyer’s Roundtable. Heading out after the festivities, I noted a very unexpected 74 degrees on my vehicle thermometer.

I am thankful to hear gentle raindrops on the roof above my tying bench this morning, even more so when I looked at the forecast promising a full inch or more of that delicious rain through tonight.

At this season, friends know they can find me along the lower reaches of the Beaver Kill, though that has not been possible yet this autumn. The river is bare, idling through dry, sun dappled rocks and gravel in a base flow condition. We all hope to get every drop of that forecast inch throughout the Catskills!

Has the season truly changed? Snow showers await per Wednesday morning’s forecast, welcomed by a high of forty-five!

I still search for the magic of the dry fly at this season, though more often than not my search will be in vain. Well, you can catch fish by nymphing, say others, for they do not understand this is not about simply catching fish. For me, the full glory of that magic comes with a lovely bamboo rod in my hand, the whirring click of a classic reel after a soft dimple envelopes the bits of feathers and fur I send drifting softly down current!

Winter offers plenty of time to wander bright waters during some break in the monotony of ice and snow, time to swing a fly deep and slow when the stream gages show a slight rise in temperature. Is it not true the Catskills may offer only a handful of days like that? Quite true, but whatever few such moments are offered are enough.

Wild trout are fascinating creatures. They are the source of our passion, rivals for our best in imitation, approach, casting and all the skills of angling, yet like us, they have their impulsive moments. There are days when I thank them for that.

Yesterday dispensed with the calm autumn beauty and bountiful sunshine featured recently and performed far more seasonably. That is to say, the wind buffeted me, turned the water into froth just downstream, and combined with the cold water to give me one of those permanent chills I have not felt since spring. Even when the water I was trying to fish sat relatively serene before me, wind through the mountains played it’s tricks just a long cast downstream. There it found a path between ridges and forest and drove the water across the breadth of the river, circling back upstream at the far shore. I mentioned to a passing drift boat that it looked like the tide was coming in.

I had not spotted any flies between the hundreds of bright leaves drifting downstream, and the chance for a rise grew ever less likely as the chill penetrated my core. All at once I saw a splash just beyond casting range, right in the wash of that incoming tide of windblown current. I concentrated upon the drift of the current and finally saw a pair of wings. The first grew into half a dozen, and I took my little Cahill from the frame of my stripping guide and pulled a length of fly line through the guides, stripping more onto the surface, just in case.

There was one smart rise in casting range, and my cast came automatically. Splash, pause, lift and hold on! I was fast to a very energetic brown trout, swirling and darting maniacally in his efforts to escape. He brought a smile to my face and laughter into my throat.

This wasn’t one of your sometimes suicidal 9-inch NYS issue stocked trout, this was a wild brownie some seventeen inches long. He was skinny for his length, and perhaps that is clue to why he alone suddenly tried to go on an impromptu feeding spree with just the barest trace of mayflies on the water. Whatever his reasons, I thank him for his service and the laughter he induced.

The wind did calm down later, the vacant river became crowded, and I walked slowly out trying to warm myself with the exertion. A few small olives brought an occasional rise here and there about the wide expanse of the pool, and there seemed to be a fisher parked on each of them. I can report that these trout failed to demonstrate the exuberance of my friend from earlier in the afternoon. They were doing a fine job of ignoring everyone’s flies!

Taking the day today, so I am not on the river, though my heart and mind is always there. I was just outside though, casting my DreamCatcher AK-47 model, spurred by thoughts of it’s namesake.

Years ago, when I first met Wyatt Dietrich along the Falling Spring to cast a few of his beautiful bamboo fly rods, he brought along one unfinished model. Guides were taped on, as Wyatt was still working out their optimum spacing, and the blank had just a base coat of varnish. He told me this was a new taper, a 7′-10″ two-piece rod for a five or six fly line, and he had a plan for this first one.

Upon completion, he followed through with that plan, shipping the rod to one Mr. A.K. Best in Colorado as a gift. He asked only that Best fish the rod and let the maker know what he thought of it. I had met A.K. Best, for he was a famous tyer of trout flies, at the first Fly Tyers Symposium. I had taken a class with Archie and found him as fine a fellow as he was a fly tyer. I told Wyatt I thought he would be favorably impressed with the rod, and he was.

This all came to mind as I was thinking about A.K. Best and his famous fishing buddy, writer John Gierach, who sadly passed away last week. If an angler did not know of Archie Best from his own books, he certainly got to know him well through Gierach’s work. I was saddened when I read the news about John’s passing, for I like many thousands of fly fishers have enjoyed his fishing tales over the past thirty years.

My own simple, private showing of loss and respect came early Sunday morning, when I sat down in the quiet of predawn and read through his classic “Fishing Bamboo” one more time.

I believe I will fish that A.K. 47 rod tomorrow, hoping to find a good trout on the fin, and I wanted to feel the bend of it with a Wulff Bamboo Special fly line. It was a perfect match. A simple ritual to send my condolences? Yes, on an angler’s wind.

I did spend some time here at my tying bench this afternoon, though not a single fly was produced. Initially I had to pluck a new supply of Wood duck flank feathers, filling the small plastic bag that nestles in my travel kit. Our Fly Tyers Guild Roundtable is coming up on Saturday, and I have to be sure I have the hooks and materials along for the patterns I decide to tie.

I picked up three packages of big-eyed dry fly hooks too, a place I have taken refuge while battling difficulties with my depth perception on the rivers this season. A size 20 olive dun spends a lot of time tied to my tippet during these last weeks of the dry fly season, and I had used up a number of those hooks putting in a store of patterns.

It seems we will have some wind tomorrow, enough to add some additional tricks to fishing such small dry flies, and to push the cool wind through lighter clothing. The first chills of the autumn season are felt more intensely after a long summer.

I have been spending considerable time considering rod tapers, flaming the culm versus oven tempering the strips, and various ideas for my winter rod project. I may have solved the taper question by looking to one of my friend Tom Whittle’s designs, published in the wonderful book “Split and Glued by Vincent C. Marinaro” that he and Bill Harms authored some years ago. Tom made my Shenk Tribute Rod back in 2021 and his taper designs are great performers.

Well, the afternoon has slipped away, and evening is upon us. I am still not used to these 6:30 sunsets, shadows on the river at two o’clock and all these signs of the deepening year…

It looks as if the warm, pleasant autumn afternoons enjoyed this week are passing, and next week will be seasonable, with daily highs from the fifties to about sixty degrees. Even as the sun kissed the water yesterday, it was clear that the few mayflies that had carried the gift of the dry fly were waning. Though the afternoon was gorgeous, I found no feeding trout.

It is early to be mourning another season’s passing, for I am used to fishing dry late into October. Nature never allows us to get too comfortable in predicting her patterns. Last year my late holiday spent hunting big fish was quiet, and this year seems it could be much the same.

There is little rain coming with that colder weather, and thus no hope for the sustenance so desperately craved by our freestone rivers and streams. The big tailwaters still flow cold with elevated releases from New York City’s dams, but their stated drawdown target has been reached, exceeded in most cases. Those flows could disappear tomorrow.

I hunted along the river all but one day this week, allowing time for the ruffed grouse opener afield. This drought year left little for me to find. A single flush was heard, though unseen through thick cover and distance, and I found the thornapples barren of their autumn fruit. All of Nature in these Catskills could use two days of gentle, soaking rain!

I cling to the joy encountered on September’s last day, the thrill of tangling with that broad shouldered brownie who dared sample my little Cahill. I may have to hold that moment in my heart now, until April.